ALL · Q4 2025 Earnings
BullishAllstate
Reported February 4, 2026
30-second summary
Allstate closed 2025 with Q4 revenue of $17.35B (+5.1% YoY), a Property-Liability combined ratio of 72.9% and underlying combined ratio of 76.6% — the cleanest underwriting quarter of the cycle. Non-GAAP EPS of $14.31 and full-year EPS of $34.83 funded a new $4.0B buyback authorization and a 7% dividend bump to $1.08, while management proactively cut premiums 17% on average for 7.8M customers — a sign they believe underwriting profitability is structural, not cyclical. The watch-list scorecard is favorable: Q4 underlying held well below 80%, homeowners ran 55.3% combined (51.4% underlying), and auto delivered a headline 80.8% combined supported by 7.5pts of favorable prior-year reserve releases.
Headline numbers
EPS
Q4 FY2025
$14.31
Revenue
Q4 FY2025
$17.34B
+5.1% YoY
Key financials
Q4 FY2025| Metric | Q4 FY2025 | YoY | Q3 FY2025 | QoQ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $17.34B | +5.1% | $17.25B | +0.5% |
| EPS | $14.31 | — | $11.17 | +28.1% |
Guidance
No quantitative guidance provided in either prior or current quarter; comparison not possible.
No quantitative guidance provided in either prior or current quarter; comparison not possible.
Segment performance
Q4 FY2025| Segment | Q4 FY2025 | YoY |
|---|---|---|
| Property-Liability | $14.776B | +6.1% |
| Protection Services | $0.917B | +3.1% |
| Allstate Protection Auto | $9.622B | +2.9% |
| Allstate Protection Homeowners | $4.055B | +14.3% |
| Protection Plans | $0.609B | +15.3% |
Capital & returns
Q4 FY2025| Segment | Q4 FY2025 |
|---|---|
| Return on Equity (Adjusted) | 38.3% |
Other KPIs
Q4 FY2025| Segment | Q4 FY2025 |
|---|---|
| Total Policies in Force | 210.9 million |
| Policies in Force YoY Growth | 3.0% |
| Property-Liability Combined Ratio | 72.9 |
| Property-Liability Underlying Combined Ratio | 76.6 |
| Auto Insurance Combined Ratio | 80.8 |
| Homeowners Insurance Combined Ratio | 55.3 |
| Total Investments | $83.2 billion |
Management tone
Q2 defensive posture → Q3 offensive rebound → Q4 capital return + customer giveback.
The defining tone shift this quarter is from "earn the margin" to "give the margin back." Two quarters ago management was framing rate adequacy as an ongoing chase against loss trends; this quarter they cut premiums for 7.8M customers by an average of 17% — a move that only makes sense if you believe the underwriting margin is structural. Wilson's framing in the release positions this as competitive offense (retention and share via affordability), not a forced concession. The signal is that Allstate views itself as having pricing room peers don't.
Capital allocation language has moved from "deploy to grow" to "return to shareholders." In Q3 the press release emphasized deploying capital to profitably grow. This quarter, the headline is a new $4.0B buyback (on top of an existing $1.5B) and a 7% dividend increase. With $7.5B at the holding company and an adjusted ROE of 38.3%, management is choosing distribution over reinvestment at the margin — a different posture than the "rate adequacy required" register of Q2.
Q&A highlights
Jimmy Bullard · J.P. Morgan
Asked about competition in personal auto, whether favorable frequency is leading to aggressive pricing, and whether recent PIF growth improvements will sustain given retention lags and new business strength.
Management stated the industry is operating rationally with moderated rate increases. New business applications up 31.2% YoY, but offset by retention headwinds from prior rate increases. Retention lags pricing changes by 12-18 months but is stabilizing. SAVE program targets 25 million customer interactions to improve retention through affordability and customer experience improvements.
Rob Cox · Goldman Sachs
Asked whether 27% new business application growth is sustainable or being flattered by unusual shopping, and whether there are any unusual items in Q1 loss ratios including tariff impacts.
Management confirmed new business levels this quarter matched end-of-2024 levels and are sustainable. Growth dependent on product rollouts in remaining states and homeowners bundling. Indicated Q4 was not 27% growth, so not expecting that level going forward. On loss ratios, emphasized quarterly comparisons lack meaning; confirmed underlying auto combined ratio of 91.3 is outstanding and broad-based across states and risk levels.
Gregory Peters · Raymond James
Asked about expense ratio trajectory over next five years and whether it can go below 20%; also asked about advertising spend variability and reinsurance program changes following catastrophe losses.
Management declined to set specific expense ratio targets but committed to continued improvement both as percentage and in absolute dollars through digitization, process elimination, and new technology platforms. Advertising spend varies with growth opportunities; Q4 was high watermark for testing. Reinsurance limits increased $1.5B (21%) to $9.5B single-event protection, split evenly between traditional and ILS markets, with cost down on risk-adjusted basis.
Elise Greenspan · Wells Fargo
Asked whether March policy growth included pull-forward from vehicles purchased in anticipation of tariffs; and how management plans to address potential mid-single-digit severity increases from tariffs.
Management stated unable to determine tariff pull-forward impact. Acknowledged tariffs will increase auto repair and replacement costs but uncertain of exact magnitude; estimates range from mid-single digits to higher. Management indicated ability to manage through pricing if needed, similar to pandemic inflation response. Some offset expected from tort reform efforts. Margins currently tight with limited absorption capacity.
Alex Scott · Barclays
Asked for detailed breakdown of retention drivers, specifically how much relates to packaged business shutdowns vs competitive pressure in certain states, and timeline for recovery; also asked about premium-to-equity leverage relative to 2021 and capital capacity for adverse scenarios.
Management declined to provide specific auto retention percentages by brand, explaining composite figures obscure story; focused instead on total PIF growth metric. Emphasized retention triggers include price increases and poor customer experience, addressed by SAVE program (affordability and experience improvements), bundling (80% for new business), and stable rate environment. On capital, stated strong position with $3B at holding company, can support market share growth and tariff scenarios; noted premium-to-surplus is crude measure; capital structured with base layer plus stress capital to absorb volatility.
Answers to last quarter's watch list
What to watch into next quarter
Whether the 17% premium reduction shows up as accelerated PIF growth in Q1 — the strategic bet is that affordability re-accelerates retention and share. If Q1 auto PIF growth doesn't visibly improve from the current ~2.3% range, the give-back will look more defensive than offensive.
Auto underlying combined ratio trajectory post-giveback — Q4 underlying ran 87.6% (90.4% adjusted for favorable in-year development). The 17% premium cut takes effect into 2026; watch whether the underlying drifts above 90% as the rate reductions earn through.
Pace of the new $4.0B buyback — at the current ROE and capital position, an aggressive front-loaded execution would signal management sees limited high-return reinvestment alternatives; a slow pace would suggest preserving optionality for M&A or stress.
Sustainability of favorable prior-year reserve releases — 7.5pts of Q4 auto combined ratio benefit came from PY non-cat reserve takedowns. That well isn't infinite; the underlying is the better forward read.
Homeowners underlying combined ratio in a heavy-cat quarter — the 51.4% Q4 underlying print is unsustainable when storm season arrives. A Q2 reading in the low-to-mid 70s would validate structural rate adequacy; above 80% would reset the homeowners narrative.
Sources
- Allstate Q4 2025 earnings release, SEC filing: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/899051/000089905126000013/allcorp123125earningsrelea.htm
Get the next brief, free.
We publish analyst-grade earnings briefs the same day or morning after every call — headline numbers, segment KPIs, Q&A highlights, and tone analysis. Free during beta.
This is not investment advice.